JUSTITIA
Kerala ✦ India ✦ UAE ✦ International Legal Affairs

The Kerala Justice Sham

When Justice Goes Dark: Inside Kerala's Judicial Breakdown

Annex 1 ✦ Abu Dhabi Court Judgments ✦ Foreign Judgments

Summary of the Apex Judgment, Abu Dhabi

Abu Dhabi Court of Appeal, Fourth Department: the final judgment of 19 May 1996 fully acquitting two Indian investors and directing an investigation of their accusers.

FINAL JUDGMENT FULL ACQUITTAL APPEAL NO. 188/1996 19 MAY 1996 · 2 MUHARRAM 1417 H
United Arab Emirates ✦ Ministry of Justice

Abu Dhabi Court of Appeal — Fourth Department

JUDGMENT
Final Judgment (Full Acquittal)
DATE
2 Muharram 1417 H / 19 May 1996
APPEAL NO.
188/1996
TRIAL COURT CASE NO.
152/1996 (Criminal Offences)
PRESIDING PANEL
  • Chief Judge: Abdul Baqi Abdul Hakam
  • Judge: Hasan Shareef Al-Jafri
  • Judge: Mohammad Al-Aboodi
  • Court Secretary: Mr. Najeeb Ahmed
APPELLANT
Public Prosecution, Abu Dhabi
APPELLEES — DECLARED INNOCENT BY THE LOWER COURT
1. Mr. Panikkaveetil Kottilugal Jabir (Indian National)
2. Mr. Panikkaveetil Moideen Abdul Jabbar (Indian National)

1. Case Synopsis

An appeal by the State against an acquittal, with no new evidence offered.

The Public Prosecution appealed the lower court's verdict acquitting the two appellees of alleged resistance to a public officer and physical assault. The initial criminal complaint was lodged by Mr. Hasan Saeed Hasan, the Plaintiff, acting in apparent concert with Police Officer Ahmed Abdullah Abdul Kadir.

The Court of First Instance had already determined that the appellees were in fact the victims of orchestrated assault and misuse of state authority. Notably, the Prosecution introduced no new evidence to justify revisiting the acquittal.

Findings & Judicial Determinations

What the Court of Appeal established, point by point.

False Allegations Fabricated by the Plaintiff and Policeman

  • The Court firmly established that Mr. Hasan Saeed and the policeman Ahmed Abdullah conspired to unlawfully detain Mr. Jabir, falsely alleging criminal resistance.
  • The policeman, armed with a one-meter-long iron rod in one hand and shackles in the other, showed intent to threaten, not to execute legal process.
  • No shred of admissible evidence supported their claims. Multiple witnesses confirmed the accused neither resisted nor used force, and were themselves victims of physical assault.

Eyewitness Testimonies

Three impartial eyewitnesses, independent of the parties, were heard. Their consistent testimony discredited the prosecution's entire narrative and painted a picture of a planned act of provocation by Mr. Hasan and the policeman. See the witnesses ↓

Abuse of Authority and Due Process Violations

  • What was falsely labelled an "arrest" was in fact a forcible abduction: the agent wore no uniform, presented no badge, and acted solely on a procedural summons with no legal basis for detention.
  • The Court ruled this a flagrant abuse of legal authority, violating Articles 2 and 3 of the Penal Procedure Code.
  • The officer's conduct was found to be coercive, extrajudicial, and unlawful.

Strong Evidence of the Accused's Innocence and Moral Conduct

  • Mr. Jabir had already deposited the full sum of AED 74,000, the total amount of a cheque associated with the contested investment. An official court receipt dated 25/10/1995 substantiates the payment, and the Plaintiff later admitted it.
  • Faced with unlawful aggression, Mr. Jabir merely instructed his brother to secure the premises and call the police, a reasonable and lawful act of self-defence.
  • Medical reports confirm severe injuries to the accused.
  • Witnesses testified the accused were well-behaved, law-abiding, and acted peacefully despite provocation and threats.
  • The policeman himself issued a notarized disclaimer (17/03/1996, Ref. No. 2314/96) abandoning his complaint.

Deceitful Motives and Perjury by the Plaintiff

  • Mr. Hasan Saeed claimed to be injured, yet his medical report showed only minor abrasions.
  • He later retracted all allegations, admitting in court that he had no evidence against the accused.
  • The Court observed his conduct amounted to deliberate defamation, aided by a complicit officer in a calculated attempt to harass and falsely incriminate two innocent men.
  • Their conduct warrants thorough investigation, as already directed by the Court of First Instance and reaffirmed by the appellate bench.

3. Eyewitness Testimonies: Exposing the Truth

Three impartial witnesses, all independent of the parties involved.

WITNESS 1

Mr. Saleem Raza

A bystander. Affirmed that the undercover officer approached the shop aggressively, wielding a one-meter iron rod and banging violently on the door. The appellees identified the intruders as "thieves" and urged him to call the police, which he did. He saw police arrive and assault the appellees in the shop, on the street, and inside the police van, completely unprovoked.

"Indian, Pakistani, Bengali—all are thieves and procurers!"
WITNESS 2

Mr. Zulfiqar Ali

Confirmed the appellees did not resist the police in any form, and that they were of good reputation.

"I am a Pakistani and they are Indian—we have no connection. I am speaking the truth."
WITNESS 3

Mr. Shirban Kalobar

His account matched both prior witnesses, reinforcing the truthfulness and consistency of their statements.

Closing Remarks & Legal Reasoning

"Justice cannot be built on unsupported claims… The burden of proof lies upon the claimant."

Closing remark to the Public Prosecution's appeal (citing a saying of Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him)

The Court reiterated that justice must not be allowed to become a tool of oppression, especially when the oppressor cloaks himself in the garb of authority.

"Islamic law and positive laws alike uphold the sanctity of human dignity by protecting a person's liberty, honour, property, and life… The unlawful restriction of a person's freedom constitutes a grave and inexcusable offense, as outlined in Articles 2 and 3 of the Penal Procedures Code."

Legal and Moral Reasoning, Section 8

The accused acted with dignity and restraint in the face of blatant abuse of power, demonstrating conduct far more lawful than their official persecutors.

9. Final Judgment

After examining all evidence, reviewing all testimonies, and assessing the conduct of the parties, the Court of Appeal issued the following binding judgment:

  1. The Public Prosecution's appeal is dismissed in its entirety.
  2. The judgment of the Court of First Instance acquitting the accused is fully upheld.
  3. The accusations against Mr. Jabir and Mr. Abdul Jabbar are declared false, malicious, and unsupported by law or evidence.
  4. The case documents shall be urgently forwarded to the Public Prosecution to investigate the heinous crimes of the culprits, Ahmed Abdullah and Hasan Saeed, including assault, abuse of power, and perjury.

10. Conclusion

This ruling reaffirms the innocence and integrity of the accused, who were unjustly targeted through a conspiracy orchestrated by private and state actors. The Court condemns such misuse of police powers and judicial procedures, reiterating its commitment to uphold the rule of law and the sanctity of individual freedoms.

Signed: Judge Abdul Baqi Abdul Hakam (Presiding Judge); Secretary Fuad Ali Mahmood (Secretary).

The Judgment Summary (PDF)

Annex 1: Summary of Apex Judgment, Abu Dhabi, as filed (4 pages, signed).

ANNEX 1 · SUMMARY-APEX-JUDGMENT-ABUDHABI.PDF OPEN DOWNLOAD

Your browser cannot display the PDF inline.

Open the PDF

Related Exposé ✦ Institutional Suppression

THE MBZ 'DELETE PROTOCOL' EXPOSED: HOW A UAE SUPREME COURT RULING VANISHED INTO A SECURITY APPARATUS!

The case surrounding a UAE investor reads less like a legal dispute and more like a blueprint for institutional suppression — where a final 1996 judgment became the beginning of a coordinated campaign to erase it.

THE ALLEGATIONS · EXPLOSIVE EVIDENCE

The UAE's highest judicial structures were reportedly examining claims involving armed robbery, unlawful police conduct, kidnapping, and institutional abuse linked to officials within Abu Dhabi's security structure. As scrutiny moved upward toward the state security apparatus then overseen by Prince Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, the system shifted from enforcement to containment.

THE REVERSAL · THE 132-DAY JUDICIAL PARADOX
132DAYS BETWEEN
JUDGMENT AND REVERSAL

What makes this case particularly extraordinary is the documentary sequence: an appellate judgment branded him a Hero and a Whistleblower, followed just 132 days later by an administrative instruction, forged records and fabricated narratives were deployed to transform the prevailing party into the accused.

THE IMPACT · FORGED RECORDS DEPLOYED

Deportation orders built on manipulated documentation were circulated through immigration systems, police channels, judicial registries, and state databases — effectively replacing the court's findings with an alternative administrative reality.

Constructive Civil Death via Database Blacklisting

By embedding a fabricated assault-on-an-officer record simultaneously into immigration blacklists, preventive security files, criminal registries, and execution databases, the apparatus subjected a judicially innocent man to constructive civil death — making the lawful Judgment Creditor a permanent “Ghost” unable to return to the jurisdiction while neutralizing the Court of Appeal’s mandate from the inside out.

The UAE Mission Was Simple —
REMOVE THE MAN. ERASE THE VERDICT. PROTECT THE IMAGE.

Abu Dhabi Court JudgmentsForeign JudgmentsIndian InvestorsReal Estate UAEReal Estate Abu DhabiAbu Dhabi CaseUAE Apex CourtJudgment Creditor